We finally watched, a few days ago. Clearly I wasn't overwhelmed by squee, because it took me a few days to post.

I don't want to rain on anybody's squee, so if you thoroughly enjoyed The Ark of Truth, you might want to go elsewhere. I didn't hate it, but I was a bit disappointed. I guess I expected too much, having waited so long. But what can you get when you condense an entire season's arc into 142 minutes?

The answer: lots of explosions, Cam Mitchell being beaten to a pulp, too many enemies, and not enough character development. The same problems affected Farscape's Peacekeeper Wars, though a little less--they had more hours! Clearly, we needed a mini-series! Um, maybe not.

Here's my major problem: the whole movie hinged on an ethical dilemma that got little more than lip service. Is it right to use coercion to force people to believe the truth? (Who decides? How do we know what truth is?) Daniel does seem deeply troubled by the idea, but even he never really seriously debates it. They simply don't have time. The dilemma is never a real dilemma; what ought to be a central conflict simply doesn't emerge as a conflict at all. We know from the start that they're going to use the Ark. I'd have been shocked (and possibly very pleased!) if they didn't. This problem is symptomatic of my difficulties with later SG-1 and most of SGA: moral dilemmas don't matter. The writers generally nod to them (but occasionally ignore them), but we rarely see a character truly struggle with them as we did in earlier SG-1 (is it wrong to poison all the Goa'uld at the summit, killing their hosts but saving future victims? Can we force an entire race, the Gadmeer, to go or remain extinct, to save a small group of humans?), or show regrets. Lately, they regret when choices aren't effective; they rarely regret doing wrong. (Yes, there are exceptions, for which I am grateful.)

On a much more nit-picky note, I am tired of watching what appears to be the same small patch of woods serve as New Athos, New New Athos, new Atlantea, planet in another galaxy, etc. I suppose I don't have a right to complain, because I remain a fan of Doctor Who and Blake's 7; Paul Darrow swears they really were once on location running around a bend in the quarry when they ran headlong into a DW team running the other way. I'm now waiting for the Torchwood crew to smack into a Doctor Who crew (ow!).

I must also complain that SG-1 should have had ground-penetrating radar that would show the location of the underground chamber (as should previous generations of seekers!). I could handle it if they offered shielding as an excuse: "But the scans were identical to the surrounding areas!" I'm not impressed with the writers' understanding of the tools available to an extraordinarily well-funded (and desperate) archaeologist. I'm also not impressed with how obvious it was once Daniel had his "vision" of Merlin, after we heard how eons' worth of people on both sides had sought the Ark. Take out a few explosions, guys, and put something remotely convincing on the ground there!

Do we need a crazy IOA operative carrying out a crazy IOA directive? I for one did not. Nor did I need to see Replicators yet again. I felt like I'd seen it all before, although non-human-form Replicators taking over a human being added a new level of horror. I felt sympathy for the poor IOA idiot for a little bit, but...it passed.

Do we need to see Cam beaten to a pulp again? Yes, I know Ben Browder singled that out in at least one interview (no, I don't have a link handy; sorry) as Cam's major function. I really could have done with a lot less of it, though. I got the idea pretty early in the fight. I wanted to see something new from Cam, some development. I suppose I've been waiting for that for most of his time on the show, sadly. It's not Ben Browder's fault. They never quite gave the character the depth he needed.

It would have been nice to see Sam doing something new, too, but at least she didn't get beaten up, making her the only one who didn't. Go Sam! They didn't give her a whole lot of initiative, though! Come on! She's going to command Atlantis! Let's see some leadership here!

I like Landry. This seems to put me in the minority. I didn't feel like he really did anything in this movie, though! Letting the Prior through to Earth just seemed dumb. We know the inhibitor that stops Priors' powers doesn't work forever. At least they took his staff away. And I did get to admire Landry's eyebrows yet again.


I did like some elements of the movie!

Tomin was the surprise highlight of the movie for me. Tomin actually has ethical struggles and character development, though his reaction to the Prior's death is rather underwritten. His acceptance of guilt, and his reluctant return to his own galaxy without his wife, whom he still loves, to try to clean up the mess, helped redeem the movie for me. I also like his assertion that the Book of Origin has some good in it. Now there's something interesting!

Teal'c shares what he has learned from his own journey with Tomin. Was his speech to Tomin not the longest speech Teal'c has ever given? He has been waiting years to share his burden. Jack and Sam wouldn't quite understand, and he can't say these things to Daniel (part of it amounts to "you forgive me to make yourself feel better", which may be true, but not something one says to the person who has graciously forgiven you). Teal'c doesn't go easy on Tomin, and his anger at Tomin surely reflects some lingering anger at himself. They both seem the better for the talk, though.

Then, of course, we get Teal'c the Persevering, who will doubtless be a figure of Jaffa legend for centuries to come, as he should be.

I liked the final scene between Cam and Sam (that was a friendly kiss such as she might have given Teal'c or Daniel, and you'll never convince me otherwise!). I knew the moment we saw Cam in the infirmary that she'd bring macaroons.

It was nice to get a little closure on Morgan, though I'm curious about whether she overcame Adria or they are simply locked in eternal combat as Anubis and Oma were (last we knew). I was glad to see Daniel's visions weren't really "visions," as that would be a little too supernatural and convenient (whereas I'm happy to accept that an interfering Ancient continues to be an interfering ancient).

Daniel hasn't finished his journey. He gives up; haven't we been expecting this for years? As he bounced back from trauma after trauma, death after death (is it [livejournal.com profile] aurora_novarum who says he has a Weeble gene?), I have to admit I finally began to disengage from the character. It wasn't so much the increasing snark (which I could mostly understand) or even his increasing willingness to use violent and fatal means. Daniel seemed to have stopped developing. That's a problem in long-running shows, but in life, and in good fiction, one always has more to do, further to go. People who stop growing aren't interesting. Daniel became interesting again in the movie. Though I wish more than lip service had been paid to the problem of using the Ark, I liked the depth of concern that Daniel showed, even as he used it.

Most of all, I enjoyed seeing the team again, especially with each other, all together and in various combinations. I was happy to see them going off again at the end. There are other adventures to be had. And I may write some of them, if I ever get time again.
Tags:

From: [identity profile] rdamel.livejournal.com


Robert Cooper, in the commentary, said very specifically that Sam's kiss to Cam at the end was "just" a friendly kiss. As CJ was making a joking remark about Sam being "kind of a slut", presumably because she's supposed to be in love with Jack, etc.
Joking aside, I saw that as "just friends" who are happy they are alive. My reaction to the dvd was much like yours--I don't want to take away from the fun of those who loved it, but it didn't do all that much for me, and I am hoping, so much, that I will like Continuum much better. I still want it to do well, though, because I'd like more SG dvd movies.

Melissa M.
ext_3557: annerb icon with scenes of all team variations, my OTP (SG-1 Kickin Ass)

From: [identity profile] aurora-novarum.livejournal.com


Hmm, I have used the "weeble gene"...I think even in a fic, but I'm not sure if I coined it or not. It seems a natural analogy to Daniel. :-)

I loved the Sam and Cameron interactions. And the team looks and moments with each other. And Teal'c so owned this movie. And I loved the development of Tomin (considering I found him dull in Crusade, my love for him is a complete 180).

And I loved the moments with Morgan. And these moments will let me enjoy it and watch it again. It was an enjoyable movie.

But...if they want to milk this franchise continue with more movies, they'd better write tighter storylines. I think RCC being writer and director and producer was a bit too much carte blanche. The plot holes and inconsistencies ran rampant.

I did read a review on some kind of "disney" website that I thought was an excellent, if a bit too biting for my taste notation of the movie and its faults.

From: [identity profile] cleothemuse.livejournal.com


My biggest gripe was that the Replicator storyline took way too much time from the Ori/Ark plot. I know they were trying to make it a "team" movie (nearly equal importance for all five team members), but SURELY they could have found something else for Sam and Cam to do that didn't detract so much from the whole friggin' point of the movie.

Overall, I am satisfied with the movie. It was WAY too fast, skipped over some important points for the sake of brevity (the moral implications, Daniel's "giving up", etc.), but it does tie up the Ori storyline. More importantly, it paves the way for some new adventures. Bring on Continuum!

From: [identity profile] delphia2000.livejournal.com


You haven't shaken my joy any, altho I can see your points. I see it as a big old fanfiction with Cam whump for his h/c fans. :oP And I agree about Sam's kiss...just friends, but doesn't mean they don't have benefits when they feel like it. *giggles* At least they didn't treat him like he was a superhero who didn't have to spend time in bed after that much stomping.

For me, Teal'c and Tomin were the best parts, especially Tomin and I'm only sorry he didn't take Vala with him. They have such chemistry together...and she doesn't with Daniel jmho.

I'm not as eager to see the next one as I don't like the way they treat time travel stories and that plot line is wearing pretty thin for me. Also, I see it as an excuse to promote the old S/J ship which I've always believed they would do at the end when they thought they could get away with it. Any slash leanings aside, I just never saw them together. All those male writers are just the worst at doing romance in any form and I'll be sorry if we're subjected to it. :oP

However, I do miss the team, the 'real' team. *sigh*

From: [identity profile] maimat.livejournal.com


ya, that sure sums it. I saw it a bit ago... and... I'm glad it wasn't expensive. I totally agree with you, more story less explosions. Don't they see that it would be a better movie and a cheeper one with a few less booms?
nialla: (Tied Up)

From: [personal profile] nialla


Less booms might be cheaper, but it means they'd actually have to write a decent plot. I'm just not seeing that happening with the current writers.
nialla: (Torchwood - Chocolate)

From: [personal profile] nialla


As you'll soon see, this is an Ianto icon as well, though it's not spoilery. In fact, I think it fits me quite well even without the Torchwood connection. ;)

Ianto's getting quite a bit of development this season, and I'm really liking it. From what I'd heard, originally his character was under consideration to be killed in the first season, but they liked the actor enough to keep him. I'm really glad they did.

I'm curious to see where the Jack/Ianto thing leads. I'm almost getting over my initial freakout that we're getting canon slash in a non-gay oriented show, and sci fi nonetheless. I'm trying to decide how the connections "really" are -- Jack and Ianto are very obviously having a physical relationship [fans self], but then there's still Gwen mooning over Jack and Jack seeming to return at least some of that feeling.

I know with Jack I shouldn't get too worked up over him being with people of both genders, even at the same time, but I get the feeling Ianto has really fallen for him, and is trying to keep his feelings to himself because he knows how Jack is and probably thinks Jack's in it for the fun and doesn't want anything more serious. If Jack breaks Ianto's heart, I'll have to kick his 51st Century ass. ;)
nialla: (Torchwood - Surrounded by Idiots)

From: [personal profile] nialla


From what I've heard, I don't think he was going to survive Cyberwoman, but I don't know at what point that change was made. If you can't tell, I tend to go for the snarky and/or geeky types, so I'm really glad they not only kept him alive but gave him a personality.

I don't think I could write real slash either, though I certainly have nothing against reading it. ;) That's one reason my writing is the weird parody it is -- I can poke fun at all sides while enjoying all sides too.

Don't worry too much about delayed viewing of the episode after Something Borrowed. It had some good moments and was kinda creepy, but it was definitely not a fave. The two after that though? Oh my, yes. ;)
nialla: (Sam and the Writers)

From: [personal profile] nialla


Do we need to see Cam beaten to a pulp again? Yes, I know Ben Browder singled that out in at least one interview (no, I don't have a link handy; sorry) as Cam's major function. I really could have done with a lot less of it, though. I got the idea pretty early in the fight.

You know what really bugged me (pardon the RepliPun) about Cam getting the crap beat out of him? There was no real reason for it other than a shot at some cool f/x.

The RepliZombie (and yes, that'll be in the Breadbox Edition *g*) attacked Cam because he was a threat... but the first thing it did was to take Cam's weapon away and toss it aside to physically attack him. WTF? Why not just shoot him, why would it want to take the more difficult route of attacking him mano a manobug?

Why in the hell would the Replicators even want to create a RepliZombie in the first place? There's no real strategic advantage, because the bugs could kill you just as dead as a RepliZombie in the long run. I think it was a cheap plot device so the "bad guy" got punished, and all this particular bad guy needed was a mustache to twirl, perhaps while tying a woman to some railroad tracks. I was reminded of Burke from Aliens, who tried to fuck over the other humans for a profit by bringing home an alien, but ended up getting his just desserts by getting the end he'd intended for others. Sorry Bridge, but James Cameron did it way better.

I think someone in the writer's room came up with the "RepliZombie turns into a RepliSkeleton" idea, the f/x guys creamed their jeans, and a stupid plot device was born.

There were some good moments, but not nearly enough. So many people seem to be using "It was just like another episode!" as praise, but to me that was a major problem. The writers have to expand their horizon a bit if they want people to shell out money to buy the DVDs. Why should I pay about half what a full season would cost, for one long episode? The scripts have got to improve, but I've been saying that for years.

I never want to see the Replicators again, and they totally did not belong in this movie. We've been there, done that, blew up the damn things too many times to count (and I loved all the P-90s firing and detroying them, yet not leaving bullet holes in the walls). I'd like them to be buried in a deep, dark hole, along with Vala's shiny "Hey, shoot me in the head, along with the rest of my team!" barrettes. ;)

And yes, the Muse is just getting warmed up. ;)
nialla: (Teal'c)

From: [personal profile] nialla


I wanted to like Vala, but she just sticks out like a sore thumb so much, and not just because of the shiny barrettes. I love Claudia Black, and I probably would have enjoyed Vala in another show, or even in SG-1 as a recurring "trickster" type character, but I just can't buy her as a regular member of the team unless she acts like a regular member of the team.

Even Teal'c, with all his years as First Prime (he probably could have crushed most of our military guys like bugs) had to learn to adapt to the way the team works, so why should Vala be such an exception? Even though Daniel's not military and often goes outside that box, he still ultimately has to follow the basic rules, because they're there for his safety as well as that of his team.

Speaking of team, someone needs to inform the writers they don't have to do an "A story" and "B story" in a movie, which invariably separates the team. Though I imagine this is partly because they're looking beyond DVD sales to when it will show on tv.

The Muse is already coming up with this whole saga for the random military guy we saw more than once shooting at the Replicators. He had "red shirt" practically tattooed on his butt, and he didn't die, so there's got to be something to that, right? Perhaps he's just been around Daniel enough that he's caught the "can't die" bug?

I don't have high hopes for Continuum, unfortunately. Jack + Temporal Wankfest = Sam-N-Sir Wuv Fest, with a probable reset button at the end. I think I want time travel plots tossed into the same pit with Replicators and Vala's shiny barrettes.

The next movie will be the real make and break time for me, though I know MGM is really looking at Continuum as proof they can maintain the franchise via DVD. I think they're banking on RDA's appearance, but if they're putting all their eggs into that basket and not writing a decent plot, it won't matter.
nialla: (Sam and the Writers)

From: [personal profile] nialla


I love Jack. I love Sam. I hate Jack/Sam.

Same here. And I think TPTB have painted themselves into a corner with all the teasing going nowhere, especially if they want to continue using either or both characters in the Stargate-verse.

Many of those who want to see it want absolute, positive proof, but said proof means both characters can't be in the same chain of command, and at the moment, they are. It also sort of taints them, IMO, even if nothing canon actually happened until after Jack retired. It would bring suspicion on Sam most all, because in the real world if this happened, many would assume she was "doing the boss" all this time to advance her career.

From: [identity profile] lmichelle599.livejournal.com



I agree the Cam whumping was over the top along with the replicator battle. How many more of these battles must the writers subject us to? Sheesh. We also knew Merrick was a dick from the get go.

Yes, there were plotholes, but I still enjoyed it.

From: [identity profile] quarryquest.livejournal.com

Sorry - the last one posted oddly. Deleted it. This is a repost ...


Hi - and I found this via SG1Debrief BTW ... I came back to SG1 only a few months ago and being British having been 'taught' SciFi ways through Blake's Seven (Chalk Pits Rule OK!) I tend to look at things with a slightly cynical eye. I was impressed by your review and how you squeed less than a lot of people. I shall now go back into my journal and write a review myself.

p.s. Gareth Thomas told me that story about bumping into Dr Who in Betchworth Chalk Pit too. I am sure its a myth they created themselves. They **did** film in similar places and follow each other round however as the officially recognised location specialist for B7 at the moment (and having got the details about filming Dr Who and cross checked yeah I know I am sad but I am a librarian in real life) its not possible it could have happened. Sorry.

p.p.s. Yay to Beowulf too. I am staying with BF this weekend and we might get to Sutton Hoo.

From: [identity profile] redbyrd-sgfic.livejournal.com


Well, I finally got to watch it, and my review tracks much like yours. Loved Teal'c's speech. Really liked Tomin. Wished they'd done a bigger Vala/Tomin scene than the one we had. Liked having Daniel figure out the puzzle one more time in the heat of the moment. Didn't have quite as strong a reaction as you to the part where he gives up, but it's an excellent point. (Would have worked better if we'd seen him having more angst during the ep though. :)

Was very irritated at the cardboard IOA guy. Found the return of the Replicators underwhelming. There was a reason for the Replicator to take him over, though- remember the first thing that Cam does is shoot him- and the bullets go through the guy's body and don't have enough oomph left to destroy the Replicator. Once he's been used as a human shield though, and Cam's weapon is gone, there's nothing left for him to do.

However, worse than that- they totally screwed up the choreography of the fight scenes, and I do mean royally. See, I could have bought it if the Replicator used superstrength but moved awkwardly while Cam used his Sodan martial arts moves. But they gave the Replicator martial arts-type moves (which we have to assume were from the IOA guy's memory). And he gets an armlock on Cam at least twice, very early in the fight. Big problem. Cam should have had two dislocated elbows and that was it for him at that point. And it goes downhill from there. Trust me, this was really painful to watch. If they were going to have the Replicator know martial arts, than Cam needed to have blocked or evaded every hold- the first one he misses ends the fight. (Getting punched is a bit easier to fanwank that he rolls with it.)

And it's pretty stupid- he's clearly invaded the IOA guy's mind, so why didn't he already know where the destruct code was? And why keep Cam alive so long? (This actually reminds me a bit of the final fight in Serenity for reasons I won't go into because I can't recall if you've seen it- but Serenity does it a heck of a lot better.)

Of course far better would have been no Replicators. A technical problem involving the Ark that Sam had to solve, before Daniel could turn it on. Cam could've been beaten up by Ori soldiers. (I'd have liked a Cam and Tomin teaming up to fight Ori soldiers scene much better.)

Honestly, while they were stealing ideas from better movies, why not have stolen some of the structure of Raiders as well? The wild chase thing would have worked reasonably decently for this.

Gah. I must admit that I generally like time travel as a theme, but my expectations for Continuum, made with this writing team? Are not high. (I take it Mallozi never responded to the critique of Unending that I posted in his blog?)

From: [identity profile] redbyrd-sgfic.livejournal.com


And as someone else pointed out: The bullets don't do any damage to the blinky lights. And? In Unending, we saw the Ori follow the Odyssey to Orilla! Which is in a different galaxy! So, do they have intergalactic drives too? (That's a really major plot hole, actually, if they haven't explained it.)

Um- I posted a comment to your LJ post (probably the one complaining about the Atlantis ep with Sheppard getting stuck in the future) when I submitted the critique on Mallozi's blog. That was after we'd discussed why you didn't care about the ep- because it's set up to be John's story, and then he doesn't get to do anything. It was a while back.

From: [identity profile] redbyrd-sgfic.livejournal.com


I have seen Serenity. All I remember of the final fight was that it was brutal.

It's well established early on that the villain is a very good martial artist, way better than Mal. And yet, the final fight drags on and on- when clearly he could have just killed Mal and it would have been over. But they *also* established that the villain doesn't just want to win. He wants his victims to *acknowledge that he's right*. It's a subtle and quite effective piece of characterization, and is a *brilliant* explanation for why Mal lived long enough to turn the tables and win the fight.
.

Profile

aelfgyfu_mead: Aelfgyfu as a South Park-style cartoon (Default)
aelfgyfu_mead

Most Popular Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags