Okay! Atlantis does Memento! I'm taking some points off for being a little too obvious in their "homage" (as the writers like to call their rip-offs), but they win most of them back for some good character scenes--and for avoiding the terrible pessimism of Memento (hope I'm not spoiling the movie for anyone, but from the opening sequence you know that is not going to be a happy movie.)
Brief synopsis of my review before spoilers: I have some quibbles, but on the whole, the episode hit the right notes for me. Nice job by Alan McCullough (see what bringing new writers onboard can do? I know, he's not that new anymore, but he's newer than everyone else!). Great Rodney scenes, good Ronon, a few nice Teyla moments. And a bit of Lorne not being bland, of which I thoroughly approve.
( Read more )
Brief synopsis of my review before spoilers: I have some quibbles, but on the whole, the episode hit the right notes for me. Nice job by Alan McCullough (see what bringing new writers onboard can do? I know, he's not that new anymore, but he's newer than everyone else!). Great Rodney scenes, good Ronon, a few nice Teyla moments. And a bit of Lorne not being bland, of which I thoroughly approve.
( Read more )
Tags: